First allow me to start off on a positive note...
I love my proud, affirmed, out, black gay male friends!!!! Ya’ll are just the most beautiful things in the world to me! I love US! I love our boldness, our courage to be ourselves, unashamed and unabashed and unapologetic!
I love all my fellas rockin brooches and amazing bags like me, giving fierce chic every time you step out the door!
I love the ones whippin their hair (real or imaginary) back and forth like Miss Willow. Or the ones with the full beat face and 5 inch stilettos. Even when I think ya’ll being extra as hell, I still love your PRIDE and CONFIDENCE and SPIRIT!
I love my brothas who give not a thought to the world of style; who enjoy hard liquor, loose denim, and sporting events, but who will walk hand in hand with their partner any damn place they fell like and DARE anyone to say something or look at them cross-eyed!!
And all those in between these extremes, I LOVE YOU!!!
We- along with our straight brothers and sisters, and our white brothers and sisters, and all the other brothers and sisters of other persuasions- are the salt of the earth, the light of the world, that cannot be hid, for we are self possessed and self-loved!
NOW....
I have HAD IT with the unaffirmed black gay men!!!
I’m trying to use the right terminology, because i am talking about a wide range of men, encompassing but beyond those that are the “typical” DL man (as defined by JL King and Oprah). But for the ease of writing, we will just refer to them all as DL and interject specific behaviors as necessary....
I am sick to death of the subterfuge, the self denial and deceit, the chaos they are causing the gay and straight communities! Not to mention the damage they are doing to themselves thats just plain....stupid and sad!
And before I go any further, let me just say this: I have a distaste and disdain for any group of people who’s MO is self-loathe and loathe of others that are not like themselves and that feel threatened by that which they do not understand or thoughts and behaviors which they do not themselves subscribe to. Whether this is based on race, nationality, sexuality, socio-economic level, etc. On an individual level, i feel very sorry for and compassionate toward them, but as a whole, I want to BEAT THEM UPSIDE THE COLLECTIVE HEAD!!!
Now, back to the DLs....
My frustration with them has been growing for some time now, and has escalated exponentially in the last several weeks. But I suppose the events of today was just the straw that broke the camels back.... and broke my silence regarding their insidious behavior!
Because I have a big mouth, and can be a touch preachy and judgemental when i see blatantly pathological thoughts and behaviors that are keeping both the individual and the community as a whole from reaching full potential, I try to avoid such negativity and such negative people. It just makes things easier for everyone. But I believe in “tell the truth, shame the devil”, so once i see wrong, i can’t help but in my inimitably-direct, but southernly-tactful way, give the offender what for.
So here it is....
I met a man today. Well actually i met him last night online. Everything was respectful, respectable and above board. He came across as (and i will even venture to say, indeed is) an intelligent, educated, handsome, amiable man of almost 40 years old (though he doesn’t look it) . We agreed this afternoon to meet at Starbucks after he got off work and before I went to pick up my niece and nephew from school. (Prefer to support small businesses, but i was fiending for their Caramel Apple Spice...which they jacked up the price of in the last 2 weeks!!! so mad!)
Now to my knowledge, from our convo and from his profile, he’s not Out, but came across to me as the kind that is merely private, and not out to the whole world, but to those that count, like family and close friends. I have come to understand that for a lot of black gay men, Out means “clockable” or noticeably gay --like me. Their outness means the world can tell without them saying anything, NOT that they are affirming their gayness to the world, which is what the term really means...I digress, but I think thats an essential fact to understand the problematic paradigm.
So my profile clearly states that I am Out, and he never asks the inevitable questions about my degree of “masculinity” or “femininity”, as we focused more in our brief but pleasant discussion on more substantive matters, as both our profiles were relationship-centric. Usually at this point, I would direct an interested party to my Facebook page in order for them to see a fuller, more robust representation of who I am as a man, so that they are not caught of guard and can graciously bow out before we begin if they feel the need, but I neglected to do so in this case. Whether you think this is wise or not to do, it has served me well and helped me to cut through the riff-raff and the small minded. So now you have the back story...
I’m dressed very casually. Grey turtleneck, black cardigan, jeans, one ring, just my wallet and phone...no bag, just not needed. He’s running late so i go back to my car to get my bag which has my sketch pad...I figured I’d occupy my time creatively. I go back and I am sitting at the table sketching a fabulous trench coat, when my friend Vic walks in. We start talking while we wait for our respective coffee-companions. I see him walk in behind Vic and go get in line for coffee. He sees me too. I wrap up with Vic and go join him and introduce myself. He’s wearing a flawless houndstooth top coat, probably cashmere...extremely dapper! I like! He goes to the table first while i get my Apple Spice. Once I get it, I join him at the table, move my bag out of my chair, and sit down. Now, either he has already seen by androgynously large Chanel tote (demure Chanel, not in your face) or he notices it when i remove it from my chair, but in either case, he notices it. He abruptly says “ I can’t do this...the bag...its just not me.” I’m stunned. I say ok, thats fine and he walks out.
I just sit there and return to sketching. Part of me is in shock and doesn’t know what to do as I process the turn-about that just occurred. The other part of me is embarrassed as hell because Vic is sitting right behind me and I’m thinking I just was stood up in front of a friend! Quelle Horreur!!! LOL! So moments later, i get a text from the guy apologizing for being rude and what not. I start to text him back, but before I can finish he calls. He pretty much apologizes again and tells me that he’s active in the community and the church (quelle suprise!) and really wants and needs a relationship with a guy who is unassuming (or unclockable) and thus can be seen with without anyone assuming that they are a couple, and that obviously that wouldn’t be possible with me. He says “I guess I’m a down-low brother”, but its just the way he lives and how he has to have it. He tries to “comfort” me by telling me to be myself and that I’m fine, but that he just can’t do it. I am, as usual, inerrantly calm, composed, poised, and gracious, taking an air of caprice and non-chalance about the whole matter, accepting his earnest apology. I hung up and finished my drink, finished my sketch, say goodbye to Vic and his friend, and went to get the kids.
Naturally, my mind is racing. I am fine. I am not hurt or even disappointed. Just saddened and mad at the state of our community. Before I left Starbucks, I texted my dear, special friend Iajahnni and told him how much I loved and appreciated him... for you see, the previous Saturday, we walked hand-in-hand, down the avenue, enjoying a lovely fall afternoon, proudly displaying our affection for each other as gay men. We could be friends, we could be lovers, we could be partners, but what we were didn’t matter to us, nor what the world around us may have thought; all that mattered was that we were together and the bond we shared in that moment and in & throughout our friendship. And as much as I appreciated it when it was happening, I was overwhelmed with appreciation and assuredness that Saturday was what is real and good and true and that events of the last few minutes were but a sad example of what is wrong with our world....
When I got to my nephews school and got him in the car, I laid down the tone of the evening....he was going to eat (what i gave him, without argument), put on his pajamas, and I was going to write with little interruption. He was fine with the arrangement and indeed governed himself accordingly, the little dear! I came in and jotted down the major points of what i wanted to share with you all, but first what I wanted to share with the inspiration for all this...the straw that broke the camel’s back. Here’s what I wrote and sent him:
“You seem like a very intelligent and reasonable man, so I was hoping we could have a bit of discourse. Just something to make you think, and not to condemn you for being you, just as you did not condemn me for being me. I meant it when I said I accepted your apology, so this is not written out of hurt or any such emotion, but in the spirit of reflection and honesty and trying to bring people together to understand and accept each other for their differences....
When you abruptly left our meeting today, i was surprised because i was not expecting that response from anyone, but especially someone of your obvious background and sophistication. (that coat was classic!!) Yes, it was rude, but I couldn’t even get to the rudeness for the shock. By the time you called minutes later to apologize for your rudeness, i was getting over shock and couldn’t even pause to consider the rudeness for what immediately felt like fear on your part, especially from your explanation of your behavior. It wasn’t so much rude that you left, and the way that you left wasn’t really rude at all as you just didn’t walk out, but gave a decent reason why you were not comfortable enough to stay, but it was more like a flight out of fear that somehow such an encounter at a coffee shop would compromise your entire existence,as you know it.
When we were on the phone and you explained yourself, you spoke of your position in the community and how you didn’t want to jeopardize that and how you wanted a relationship with a man that you could go out with and people not think either were gay, but just two friends spending time together. I can understand that totally, even though i don’t share that desire for anonymity or ambiguity. But my immediate thought was even though you recognized off the bat that I could not provide the kind of anonymous, ambiguous relationship you seek, why was your response to immediate flee?? There was another viable option, that would have been perfectly polite, correct, and left both of us not feeling as we did: you could have stayed and gotten to know me as a person....
Here’s how that would have played out: You recognized i was “clockable” and made your decision that romance was out of the question. When I came to the table and sat down with my caramel apple spice, you would have sat as well and proceed to make polite, sparkling conversation with a man who has already shown his wit and intellect to be desirable to you on some basic level. We would finish our drinks, say our goodbyes and go our separate ways. You would then call or text me and say that though it was a pleasure meeting me, you didn’t think a romantic relationship would be possible, but that friendship was possible, if i so desired. Provided I found you equally enjoyable, i would have accepted the invitation to friendship, and we would have carried on from there. But none of that occurred because of fear.
My carrying a bag- and the supposed subjective “femininity” that that conveys-incited a reaction in you because you felt that by mere association you would be perceived of as gay. That somehow MY gayness or effeminacy in someway would reflect negatively on YOU and cast some sort of dispersion on your character and call your masculinity into question. Why is that?? Its is a common misconception, but its one that must cease.
If you were to stay and have coffee with me, and remained warm and friendly, but adequately distant befitting a first meeting, the viewing public would have assumed that we were friends or colleagues. And even future meals or outings would have illicited the same opinion and judgment of friendship. If your masculinity- nay, your manhood- is in tact, there is nothing that i could ever do to compromise that. I have straight male friends and family members that i hang out with frequently who are very comfortable being seen enjoying my company and i theirs, and neither they nor the general public suspect any form of homosexuality or queerness in our association. But your fear of being discovered as something other than what you present to the world creates a discomfort in you that keeps you from befriending someone as wonderful as i am simply because they/I are/am proudly themselves/myself. And thats just sad and unfortunate because of the awesome experiences you could have that are denied before they even have the possibility of blossoming.
Again, I say all this not to indict you or make you feel bad for what happened, but I had to say something because I am committed to bringing people together and ending the animosity between all people that derives from fear and ignorance and misunderstanding. I will not be hurt nor my life altered if i never heard from you again, but if my words free you to be yourself or to love and enjoy the company of someone else as a friend or lover that is somehow different than you, then this whole experience has not been in vain and I have replaced some of the discord of our world with a single note of harmony.
Feel free to respond positively if you like. If you have nothing positive to say in response, then keep it yourself please, and I wish you well.
Thanks,
Charles”
I think this was a sublime way of taking a negative, and trying to find some kind of positivity in it....
But I’m not through yet....As I said, certain events of late have been annoying me and I have stayed still, but I can’t any longer. so since the floodgates are open, i must continue. For those of you who have made it this far, Bless You! I know I am long winded. But manifestos are never short epistles....This is why the modern activists do podcasts and Vlogs! LOL! But I’m old school....the black gay male Gloria Steinem!
~
Being OUT
I understand the reasons for not being out. Really I do. I was at one time, not out. But even when I wasn’t out, the world treated me as though I was. While i resented this fact at one time, I came to realize after the fact, that it made the transition rather seamless by comparison to some others’ experiences. I never had the opportunity to come out to the world, as society assumed that because of my intellect, my sophistication, my articulation, my organizational skills (all reasons Barack isn’t black enough), as well as my sartorial flawlessness and innate sense for all things chic, elegant, and glamorous, that I must be gay. Though they were right, i do know a few very hetero men with many (if not all) the same attributes, so these traits alone do not a gay make. But I digress. Because of these things, being out once i finally accepted who i was, was not a big deal in readjusting to how the world saw me. While it was a blessing for me, i understand that this transition in they eyes of the world is at the heart of why most DL men wont or can’t come out.
The DL are fearful or rejection, of unjust hardship socially and economically and I understand all of this rationale. I have dated men that didn’t consider themselves Out...or not as Out as i was/am. I think their definition of what it meant to be Out was a little off, because it was based on surface things, rather than on hopes and beliefs internal. But nonetheless, they considered themselves not Out as it were. Yet, they reveled in me being me, for all my fabulousness. They never shied away from me in public or private and they embraced my uniquity. They proudly sat close in restaurants, held my hand or embraced me with great affection in stores and wherever we went, when the mood struck either of us. This was enough for me. How they chose to negotiate their disclosure in their professional lives was of little consequence, but in their social lives and in their heart i knew i had a place of priority and pride.
While their numbers are FAR from legion (and far from what I would like them to be! lol!), there are men that do exist IN TRUTH in this middle space between being In and Out of the Closet. I would for them to come all the way Out for themselves and for the upbuilding of our communal kingdom, but so long as they are in some form of Truth that allows them to not be shameful or secretive, but merely relatively private, then so be it. They will continue to progress on their own trajectory at their own speed.
But the ones who live in fear and shame and who try to project that shame in some way, shape or form on US for fully embracing ourselves and our diversity, i have NO tolerance for! Their lack of courage and their inability and unwillingness to appropriate their own identity, makes them less than a man in my eyes! I garner more respect in all my “femininity” from men and women alike for my self-possession and confidence and wisdom than any of them do, and they need to know and see THIS truth! They are not fooling anyone! Whether anyone can tell exactly what their secret is, it is evident that there is a secret that is keeping them from being the shining light of love and life that every human should be, who lives in love and in truth.
The lies of the closeted black gay man, weakens the whole of us. It denigrates all that we stand for. It detracts from our assertions that we are happy, healthy and worthy of the same human, spiritual, civil, and economic rights as anyone else. It propagates and perpetuates the founded-but-nonetheless-detrimental stereotype of the maladjusted, dysfunctional black man. It has to stop! I’m tired of feeling held back or being looked at as less than by the world-at-large because of the weaker--sorry, WEAKEST-- members of our community! And although some may assert, that because they don’t accept themselves, we shouldn’t consider them part of the community, well thats a lie. They are a part of the community, whether we or they want to be. And just like the liabilities of the larger black community, though we may want to, we cannot just lop them off and go about our business, because the establishment is always going to affix them back to our rear end!
So what are we to do with these problematic blights? There isn’t much we can do, unfortunately. But what we can do is STOP engaging them. I mean it....STOP dealing with them electively. We can’t help it if we work with them, but in any other setting, shun them the way they shun us! Yes, this seems very exclusionary and negative, but what has being inclusive and embracing of them- in their mess- gotten us or them?? Not a damn thing!!! They think they can have their cake and eat it too....be part of our world when they want and then a part of the world that derides and berates us the rest of the time. Well i say NO! You can’t have it like that and I for one am not going to let you. (YES, I’m talking to them now!)
When you are ready to take steps toward real integration, I will be the first to greet you with open arms and take you by the hand and show you the way, baby. But until then, you gets no love!....
I’m not going to befriend you on FB, Myspace, A4A, BGC or any other social network
I’m not going to “kiki” or kick it with you at our or your clubs and functions
I’m not going to have any kind of sexual or romantic encounters with you
I’m not going to sympathetically listen to your plight, when you have the key to ending it but refuse to....
Just like you say “No Fems!”, I am going to say even louder and with more conviction (because you know you will have sex with a fem and grind on a fem on the dance floor in a hearbeat!) “NO DL!!!”
And I’m talking primarily to/about the DLs that exclusively mess with men and have no interest at all in women. I REALLY don’t have time, sympathy, or anything at all to say to those who are playing on both teams. They really need to not be getting any kind of attention or grace from the Out members of the community! Its not even just a moral issue of disrespecting the women they are with and lying to, but an issue of integrity and principle of respecting and honoring ourselves and our Proud, Courageous, OUT Brethren to demean all that we are proud of and fought for in order to engage in discourse and intercourse with someone(s) that clearly is an affront to what we stand for as individuals and a group!
I will make one exception for the youth, who are really still trying to figure it out, but for those of a certain age (maybe 23, definitely 25 and up) who are grown men, that have made a firm decision to not embrace our life and culture...fuck em! I mean it...FUCK THEM!!!
Yes its harsh, but its tough love. Like I said, when they show some sign that they are ready to receive what we have to offer them, we should give it to them freely, but until then, no. They can get what they need from each other. The DL can feed off each other till doomsday for all i care, but the parasites won’t feast on us any longer!
They say they don’t want us anyway, then FINE! Don’t be coming for our fine specimens like Dr. David (Malebranche) who not only have looks to die for, but who has the brains and heart to match....NO! You go find your own...you go find your spineless, cowardice, punk-ass counterpart and talk to them, wine and dine them, and f*ck them! And don’t you dare come over here for our young and our weak, who haven’t figured out yet who they are or have low self-esteem elsewhere in their lives, but whose only source of self-assuredness is as a gay man, part of the gay community, and think you will use their vulnerability and generosity of spirit and longing for acceptance from the world (your world) so that you can feel good about your sorry self, and feel some kind of power since you are too emotionally and spiritually impotent to have any real power, and get your rocks off at their expense (Eddie Long and his ilk!)!!!! I be DAMNED!!
So Brothers, its up to us to take a stand and just say “NO to DOWNLOW!”
~
And by they way....I MUST say, I am so tired of the DL coming out in droves at gaydom’s most salacious, ridiculous, debasing events! The only time you want to encounter us socially is when someone is slangin dick and getting drunk!!! NO..None of that! Though I don’t care for those kinds of events, I have earned the right to go if I choose, because I have taken the good with the bad, the pretty with the ugly when it comes to US and I can go wherever the hell I please as a reward! But ya’ll parasites need to back the hell off and have your own damn orgies or whatever the hell ya’ll need or want to do!
And for the ENTIRE community , DL and Out, the party at night needs to be the reward for those that came to the workshops and seminars in the morning and marched protest or parade in the afternoon.....but thats another rant!
This is all I can muster for one evening...and it has taken literally all evening (6pm-11pm CST) . But there is soooooo much more to say about the community and how we really must start embracing ourselves and each other... without shame, without fear.... with sincerity, with camaraderie, with warmth, and putting aside all the foolishness and the bull, and those in and out of the community that seek to do us no good....